Australian-Style Pies at Pie Face

Menu Smiley faces all over the place

Large savory pies Mini sweet pies
Exterior and Interior of Pie Face; Savory and Sweet Pies

I’m a big fan of pies. I don’t care if it’s sweet or savory. I’ll eat them all. This lead me to the Australian-based bakery Pie Face in Midtown West, about a block from the Sullivan Theater.

Inside this corner bakery, you’ll be seeing a lot of adorable smiley faces (or cute semi-frowns), as it’s the company’s way of deciphering the seven different flavors of pies. The flavors are globally influenced but some are familiar. There were sandwiches, wraps, and soups but I was there mostly for the pies.

Humorous lingo on their coffee menu My Flat White, "Kick My Arse" strength
Coffee menu and my Flat White, “Kick My Arse” strength

Curious about their coffee, I ordered the Flat White, “Kick My Arse” strength (the strongest brew; medium size $3.45). It was a pretty darn good cup of coffee (and it’s strong enough). If you haven’t tried a flat white before, it’s like a latte but a touch less milk. The latte art was a nice touch. It’s a good option to have a cup of coffee beyond the typical Starbucks.

There were cute names to indicate the strength of your brew such as “start my heart,” “open my eyes,” and “still asleep,” from next strongest to decaffeinated. I really admired the design of their unusual paper cup. It’s pretty ingenious that it has the ribbing all around the cup to insulate heat of the beverage from your hand.

Tray of mini sausage roll and mini savory pies Inside the mini Mexican pie
Tray of mini sausage roll and mini savory pies and a bitten mini Mexican pie

I ended up trying their mini savory pies (chunky steak, Mexican, Thai chicken, beef & tomato, chicken & mushroom) and a mini beef n’ pork sausage roll ($2.95 each). Each were tasty. They had a buttery, flaky crust and the ratio of filling to crust was pretty good. The fillings were flavorful and it had a decent amount of gravy/sauce. Of the five I had, I like the Thai chicken the most for being sort of savory, sweet, and spicy all at the same time. (If you want to gauge as to how many mini pies to order, I’d say about three pies if you’re moderately hungry.)

The sausage roll was unexpectedly my favorite. I loved how meaty and robustly flavored it was and the puff pastry was incredibly flaky. I found it a bit surprising to see fine shreds of carrot mixed within the filling but it worked.

A platter of savory pies (mini and large) and sausage rolls
Baby and regular pies Chicken n' bacon sausage rolls
Savory spread; Mini and regular-sized chunky steak pies; Sausage rolls

I brought back some of their pies and sausage rolls to share it with friends (both sweet and savory).

Of the ones that I haven’t mentioned earlier, their breakfast pie Bacon, Egg & Cheese (regular size $5.95) was delicious. If there’s bacon (or any pork fat), it’s generally bound to be good. The regular sized chunky steak pie ($5.95) was felt more substantial to eat even though I had about 1/4 of the pie, compared to the mini. The tandoori vegetable really hit my palate with its fiery spices without being consumed by heat.

Their chicken n’ bacon sausage roll was great ($2.95). I really like how they spiced the filling and I wish I could have this as my weekly weekend breakfast.

Sweet mini pies
Mini sweet pies and cheesecake

Also the mini sweet pies and cheesecake ($3.25 each) were good to have as well. The sweet pies were thankfully not sweet. The lemon pie had a very substantial amount of sweet lemon cream with a smidge of crisp crust that amazingly held up all of that filling. The cheesecake was pleasantly soft and creamy. The ricotta and pear pie was good, though the crust was a bit thick for my preference. I liked both types of apple pies. The chocolate pie was essentially a chocolate mousse tart, like the lemon pie, it had a hefty amount of mousse under a chocolate glaze.

Lamingtons Inside the Lamington
Lamingtons and its cross section

Despite eating all of those sweet pies, I was really interested in the Australian specialty cake lamington ($4.25 each) since I’ve heard and read so much about them as of the recent years. This cake was pretty darn good. The large cake cube (about 4 inches all around; easily shared between two) was a dense, fine-crumbed white cake that was moistened by the smear of sweet raspberry jam in the middle, coated in dark chocolate ganache and coconut flakes. Overall, the cake is barely sweet, moderately moist and I prefer it that way.

Pie Face is pretty much the only place I know that does sell both savory and sweet pies in Midtown that does taste delicious. Their coffee is very good compared to a certain nearby coffeehouse. If I were around this area or have a major craving of pies, this would be my go-to spot for pies to go. The pies do keep well overnight that it doesn’t burst in my oven when I take it out directly from my fridge and place it into my oven.

To view more photos of my visit, please click through the slideshow (or view my Flickr set):

[tylr-slidr userID=”hellokitty893112″ groupID=””]http://www.flickr.com/photos/hellokitty893112/sets/72157629546501715/[/tylr-slidr]

Pie Face

Website: http://piefacenyc.com/
1691 Broadway (on W 53rd St.)
New York, NY 10019
Telephone: (212) ­247-­9065
Opens 24 hours
Note: No seating available and standing room is limited, especially when it’s busy.


I shoot, eat, and drink. My full time job is a hospital administrator. Moonlighting as a freelance photographer and food and travel writer.

  1. cheryl spiegel says:

    Mmmm….thanks for sharing this find. I’m certainly going to check this little gem out.

Comments are closed.